Key Takeaways
- A dental practice valuation is a data-driven estimate of worth that can shape what an owner actually keeps in any transition, partnership, or sale.
- Owners can benefit from obtaining a valuation 2 to 3 years before any planned exit to identify and move the levers that increase value.
- CPA-led valuations with documented add-backs are more likely to survive buyer diligence and can reduce re-trades that erode the final price.
- The same practice can produce materially different numbers because private dentists and DSO/private-equity groups price on different earnings metrics.
- McLerran & Associates delivers sell-side-only, diligence-grade valuations that equip owners with a grounded number before they decide on next steps.
Talk To McLerran & Associates About Your Practice
When Should You Get A Dental Practice Valuation?
A valuation works as a planning tool whenever a real decision is on the horizon. Each common situation uses the number in a specific way:
- Retirement Or Exit Timing. A baseline now gives you a clear countdown you can manage. It also gives you time to move the levers that raise value before you need the number to stand up to buyers.
- Bringing In An Associate Or Partner. A buy-in priced without a defined valuation date and clearly defined assets can invite disputes later. A formal valuation sets expectations and protects both sides.
- A DSO Or Private-Equity Approach. If the first number on the table comes from the buyer, you negotiate from the buyer’s math. A valuation completed before that conversation sets your baseline.
- An Unsolicited Offer. A benchmark lets you accept, counter, or walk away based on data instead of instinct.
- Financing Or A Practice Loan. Lenders want a defensible number. Under SBA 7(a) rules effective October 1, 2026, the lender must order its own independent valuation from a credentialed appraiser, and deals of $3 million or more also require a separate quality-of-earnings review.
- Estate And Succession Planning. A documented value can be essential for family, partners, and buy-sell provisions. Non-sale purposes including estate planning, divorce, and insurance each use different standards and assumptions, so the valuation should match the intended purpose.
- Pure Benchmarking. Knowing where your margins and profitability stand against the market while you still have time to act is a valid reason to get a number.
The best time to get a valuation is 2 or 3 years before a planned sale. The levers that move value, such as overhead by category, owner dependence, hygiene mix, and lease term and renewal options, usually take 12 to 24 months to shift. A 24‑month prep window with a 12‑month minimum gives buyers at least 12 months of clean trailing-twelve-months data on any major change. A valuation done years in advance gives you time to act on what it reveals.
What Does A Dental Practice Valuation Actually Include?
A credible dental practice valuation often relies on normalized EBITDA. EBITDA means earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. In plain terms, it is the operating profit a practice generates after paying a market-rate dentist to replace the owner’s clinical production and after removing expenses that are personal, one-time, or discretionary.
Those removed expenses are called add-backs. An add-back with an invoice behind it is worth its face value multiplied by the multiple, while an add-back you can only describe carries no value. McLerran’s CPA-led process reviews every add-back line by line, including discretionary, personal, and non-recurring items, and ties each one to documentation.
Documentation matters because buyers test the numbers. After a letter of intent is signed, the buyer’s accountants run a quality-of-earnings review, which is a deep rebuild of earnings from source records. If the buyer discovers that claimed add-backs lack evidence, the buyer does more than reduce the price by that amount multiplied by the multiple. The finding can cause the buyer to question the credibility of every remaining item, which is the mechanism known as the re-trade. Because the price in a letter of intent is typically non-binding, a diligence finding can be used to revisit it.
McLerran builds its valuations by remotely accessing the practice management software, pulling reports, and cross-referencing them against the financials. The method used to calculate value depends on the likely buyer. Doctor-to-doctor deals often use a percentage of revenue or a multiple of net cash flow, while DSO and private-equity deals typically use a multiple of EBITDA. If the owner is not ready to sell, McLerran updates the valuation for free a year later.
For a deeper look at methodology, see Dental Practice Valuation Methods Explained and How To Value A Dental Practice: A 7-Step Guide.
How Much Does A Dental Practice Valuation Cost And Why Can Free Ones Be Risky?
A free valuation can quietly set an anchor that shapes the entire negotiation. A back-of-the-napkin number from a lead-generation firm or from the buyer becomes the reference point that influences what the owner ultimately keeps. Walking into a dental practice sale negotiation without your own valuation means relying entirely on the buyer’s math, which is usually built to find discounts.
Diligence risk is the second issue. A weak analysis can create a number that looks attractive at first but collapses under scrutiny. When the buyer’s accountants rebuild earnings from source records and find undocumented add-backs, the deal often gets re-traded. The owner who started with a flattering free valuation can end up with a lower price than the one in the letter of intent.
Structural conflicts also matter. A broker’s opinion of value is often free because the broker expects to obtain the listing afterward, which creates an incentive to appraise high enough to win the engagement. A buyer’s number serves a different purpose and reflects the buyer’s priorities.
The difference in outcome can be substantial. In one documented case, a free valuation pegged a practice at $2.5 million. McLerran valued it at $4.5 million, and it sold for $5.25 million after a competitive process.
For a full treatment of cost and what a paid valuation includes, see How Much Does A Dental Practice Valuation Cost? and Is A Free Dental Practice Valuation Worth It?
Schedule A Free Discovery Call
Two Markets, Two Numbers: Private Buyer Versus DSO
Cost is one variable, and buyer type is another. A dental practice valuation often produces two numbers, a private-buyer number and a DSO/private-equity number, and the same practice can draw very different offers from each market.
The earnings metric creates this gap. A private owner-user, meaning another dentist buying the practice to work in, typically pays on seller’s discretionary earnings (SDE), which adds back the owner’s full compensation at whatever level it was paid. A DSO or private-equity buyer usually pays on adjusted EBITDA, calculated after subtracting what it would cost to hire a market-rate associate to perform the clinical work the owner currently does. A private owner-user often pays 75–90% of collections with 100% cash at closing, while a DSO may pay a higher headline but deliver only 60–70% at closing, with the remainder via earnout or equity rollover.
That deferred component can carry real risk. Roughly 30–40% of a DSO purchase price held back as an earnout or equity rollover is not guaranteed. If the DSO is acquired, restructured, or underperforms during the seller’s work-back period, that deferred value may not fully materialize. Up to roughly 40% of a DSO deal can be paid in equity, which is why the owner often needs to underwrite the buyer like an investment, looking at profitability, growth at existing offices, management strength, and the sponsor’s track record.
Because McLerran works both paths in roughly equal measure, it can quantify the practice’s worth in both markets side by side. It can also build multi-year, multi-structure cash-flow models across 3-, 5-, 7-, and 10-year horizons. A single-lane advisor can show only one of these numbers. A buyer can show only its own.
For a detailed look at how the numbers differ by buyer type, see Dental Practice Valuation: Why The Numbers Differ.
How Much Do Dentists Make When They Sell, And How Hard Is It To Close A Sale?
Sale price and closeability can be some of the main factors that shape a dentist’s outcome. Each factor has its own drivers.
On price, what a practice sells for depends on size, profitability, specialty, buyer demand, and deal structure. Most general dental practices transact at roughly 70–85% of their own annual collections in a private sale. That range works as a screening tool rather than a final valuation because it ignores cost structure entirely, which is why two practices collecting the same amount can be worth materially different amounts depending on overhead, owner dependence, and hygiene mix. DSO buyers price on adjusted EBITDA and can produce a higher headline number for the right practice. The structure behind that number then determines what the owner actually receives: cash at close, earnout, or equity.
The multiple also depends partly on the process. A single buyer negotiating against nobody prices differently from several buyers who each know the others exist. Competitive tension can be a core driver of outcome.
On difficulty, a dental practice sale can be fragile and can collapse at multiple points. Do-it-yourself close rates can run as low as 15–20%, versus roughly 80% for a well-run brokered process. McLerran reports that roughly 85–90% of its clients transact, versus an industry norm closer to 35–40%.
A dental practice valuation can be a first defense against both the low price and the collapsed deal. It establishes the number before anyone else does and gives the process a defensible foundation.
Who Should Run Your Dental Practice Valuation?
If close rates and final prices depend heavily on the process, the provider running it matters. Five criteria can be applied to any provider:
- Dental-Only Specialization. The dental market has its own benchmarks, and generalists routinely misapply them. A firm that works across multiple healthcare or business verticals may lack the specialty-by-specialty and market-by-market depth that dental-only focus provides.
- Sell-Side-Only Alignment. Ask whether the provider’s compensation depends on a sale and whether it may later represent or introduce a buyer. Dental practice owners can ask whether the provider’s compensation depends on a sale or a target value, and whether the provider may later represent or introduce a buyer, since such conflicts should be disclosed and understood.
- CPA-Led Rigor. Every add-back should be unpacked and documented so the valuation can withstand quality-of-earnings diligence rather than simply capture a lead.
- Access To Both Buyer Markets. The owner benefits from seeing a private-buyer number and a DSO number instead of only one lane.
- A Track Record Of Transactions. A history of valuations that actually lead to closed deals can be more informative than valuation volume alone.
McLerran & Associates meets each criterion in turn. On dental-only specialization, it focuses exclusively on dental, with roughly 35 years in business and more than 10,000 practices evaluated at a pace of roughly 500 per year. On sell-side alignment, its client is always the selling dentist, never the buyer, and its compensation structure reflects that focus. On CPA-led rigor, every valuation is CPA-led, with each add-back unpacked and documented to support diligence. On access to both markets, its work splits almost evenly between private-buyer and DSO transactions, which supports side-by-side analysis. On transaction record, it has completed approximately 2,000 successful practice sales and roughly $2 billion in closed transaction volume. Its structured, auction-like bid process typically runs 45 to 60 days, generates around 10 offers, and produces a transaction rate of roughly 85–90%, with clients achieving on average roughly 30% higher valuations than owners who sell on their own.
The alternatives each carry documented trade-offs. Free-valuation lead-generation firms often produce a number designed to capture a listing rather than to survive diligence, and relatively few of their listings transact. Buyer-set numbers are built to find discounts. Local generalist brokers may offer limited market exposure, weaker underwriting, and only one or two DSO relationships, which can cause buyers to bid less aggressively on their deals over time. Multi-vertical advisors bring deal experience without dental-only depth. Do-it-yourself sellers face a full information disadvantage, no competitive tension, and the close-rate penalty described earlier.
McLerran can be a better fit than generic advisory or lead-generation options for several reasons. It is sell-side only, so its client is always the selling dentist and never the buyer. Its valuation is CPA-led and built to survive diligence rather than to capture a lead. Because it works both sale paths, it can show the owner a private-buyer number and a DSO number side by side, which single-lane or brokerage lead-generation approaches structurally cannot do.
The ADA advises dental practice owners to use expert professionals familiar with dental practices for valuation and to assemble a professional team before seriously evaluating a practice. McLerran’s dental-only focus and CPA-led process align with that standard.
What To Do With The Number Next
A valuation works best as an ongoing planning tool rather than a one-time appraisal. Once you have the number, you can use it in a sequence of steps:
- Start by benchmarking the number against the market and against any prior valuation so you can see whether the practice is gaining or losing value.
- Use that comparison to identify the margin and add-back levers that raise value, such as overhead by category, owner and provider dependence, hygiene mix, lease term and renewal options, and documentation quality.
- Once you know which levers matter most, set a timeline and work backward from the date you want to be out.
- Re-value as the practice changes. A dental practice valuation can be treated less like a one-time appraisal and more like a number checked periodically, the way an investor monitors a portfolio.
Sometimes the number disappoints. A candid valuation that identifies the causes of a gap and the records needed to revisit it can be more useful than a flattering one. The goal is a number you can act on.
For what comes after the valuation, see What Happens After A Dental Practice Valuation.
Conclusion
A dental practice valuation can matter even when the owner is not selling. It creates a baseline that turns a once-in-a-lifetime decision into a managed one and helps shift control toward the owner. Each key choice, such as paid or free, both buyer markets or one, and sell-side or conflicted, can influence whether the number you receive becomes a genuine business tool or an opening move in someone else’s negotiation.
McLerran & Associates is a dental practice valuation firm for owners who want to understand what their practice may be worth before they decide on a path. Its work is CPA-led, diligence-grade, and structured to show both buyer markets side by side. To discuss your practice, your goals, and your options in a free, confidential conversation, call (512) 900-7989, email info@dentaltransitions.com, or visit dentaltransitions.com/contact-us.
Get Your Practice Valued Before You Decide
Frequently Asked Questions
Is A Dental Practice Valuation Worth It If I’m Not Selling?
A valuation can be worthwhile whenever a real decision is on the table. A buy-in, financing, estate planning, a DSO approach, or a retirement date you are trying to plan against can each justify a formal valuation. As noted earlier, the levers that move value usually take 12 to 24 months to shift, so a valuation years before a planned transition gives you time to act on what it finds. Even without an imminent decision, a periodic valuation functions as a report card on whether the practice is gaining or losing value while there is still time to respond.
How Long Does A Dental Practice Valuation Take, And What Do I Need To Provide?
McLerran’s process typically requires the owner to provide access to the practice management software and financials once. From there, a CPA and deal advisor, supported by a team of analysts, remotely pull the necessary reports, cross-reference them against the financials, and build the valuation. The owner then walks through the findings in detail with the team. If the owner is not ready to sell after receiving the valuation, McLerran updates it for free a year later rather than push toward a transaction before the timing feels right.
Will Getting A Valuation Signal That I’m Selling Or Expose My Practice?
A valuation engagement with a sell-side-only firm stays confidential by design. McLerran’s client is always the selling dentist, never the buyer, and McLerran & Associates offers a complimentary practice valuation (a $2,500 value) with a one-on-one review with its team, provided before the practice goes to market. This structure differs from listing a practice for sale or engaging a firm that also represents buyers. Owners who are benchmarking, planning, or evaluating a DSO approach can obtain a valuation without creating a public signal that the practice is available.
Why Do Two Valuations Of The Same Practice Differ?
Different dates, different definitions of what is being valued, different add-back treatment, and different buyer types can each produce a materially different number without any arithmetic error. A private-buyer valuation uses seller’s discretionary earnings, while a DSO valuation uses adjusted EBITDA after a market-rate associate salary. An add-back accepted by one valuator may be challenged by another if it lacks documentation. A valuation done at a peak revenue year can look different from one done during a declining trend. For a detailed explanation of why the numbers differ and what drives the gap, see Dental Practice Valuation: Why The Numbers Differ.
What Is EBITDA, And Why Do Add-Backs Matter?
EBITDA stands for earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. In simple terms, it is the operating profit a business generates before financing costs and accounting adjustments. In a dental practice valuation, EBITDA is further adjusted by removing personal expenses run through the practice, one-time costs that will not recur, and the owner’s above-market compensation, while replacing the owner’s clinical production cost with what it would cost to hire a market-rate associate. These adjustments are called add-backs. They matter because the buyer’s accountants will rebuild earnings from source records during diligence and challenge any add-back that lacks documentation. An undocumented add-back does more than reduce the price by that amount. It signals to the buyer that other numbers may also be unreliable, which can trigger a broader re-trade of the agreed price.
Can I Get A Valuation Updated Later If I’m Not Ready To Sell?
Yes. McLerran updates its valuation for free a year later if the owner is not ready to sell after the initial engagement. This reflects the firm’s view of the valuation as a planning tool rather than a transaction trigger. Practice performance changes, market conditions shift, and the levers that move value take time to respond, so a valuation that is revisited periodically can be more useful than a single point-in-time appraisal that grows stale.
