Key Takeaways
- Most dentist-owners rely on the 70%-of-collections rule, yet this formula prices revenue rather than profit and can leave significant value on the table.
- Different valuation formulas can apply at different stages, and the right choice depends on buyer type and practice size.
- Private doctor-to-doctor sales typically use collections or SDE, while DSO and private-equity buyers price on normalized EBITDA after replacing the owner’s clinical production.
- Practices in the $1.5M–$3M revenue range benefit most from a side-by-side valuation that compares both buyer paths before committing to one.
- McLerran & Associates is a dental-specific sell-side advisor that runs both the private-buyer and DSO paths in roughly equal measure. It builds a CPA-led, diligence-grade EBITDA valuation up front and creates competitive tension among vetted buyers so the number holds.
How Dental Practice Valuation Formulas Work
Two core formulas drive many dental practice valuations. The percentage-of-collections formula multiplies annual collections by a market percentage and is common in private doctor-to-doctor sales. The EBITDA multiple formula (EBITDA = earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) multiplies normalized operating profit by a market multiple and is the standard for DSO and private-equity buyers. A third method, the SDE multiple (seller’s discretionary earnings), sits between them and is used by private buyers evaluating mid-sized practices.
There is no universally correct formula. The likely buyer and the practice’s size and profitability can be some of the main factors that determine which method applies. Using a single formula when both buyer paths are open can leave significant value on the table before a conversation even begins. For a deeper look at how these methods are defined and weighted, see Dental Practice Valuation Methods Explained.
The Three Formulas Buyers Actually Use
Percentage Of Collections (Private Doctor-To-Doctor Sales)
Formula: Practice Value = Annual Collections × Market Percentage
Published dental M&A benchmark data places many private doctor-to-doctor transactions in a range of roughly 60% to 95% of annual collections, with most deals landing between 70% and 85%. SBA-financed individual buyers tend to cluster in a narrower band toward the lower end of that range.
Several factors can push a practice toward the top or bottom of that range:
- Profitability and overhead: A practice running lean overhead earns more from the same collections and often commands a higher percentage.
- Hygiene share and recall: Hygiene revenue above roughly 25%–33% of collections and strong recall rates are favorable indicators that support the top of the range.
- Owner dependence: A practice where the owner produces the large majority of revenue is harder to transfer and typically prices toward the lower end.
- Payer mix: Practices with at least 60% private-pay revenue can command higher percentages, while substantial Medicaid exposure can suppress pricing.
- Equipment, facility, and lease: Modern operatories and a long, assignable lease support value. Aging equipment and a short lease usually discount it.
- Location and market demand: Practices in growing metropolitan markets may receive a premium compared with slower-growth areas.
These factors explain why the range is wide and also highlight a structural weakness in this formula. The collections method prices revenue instead of profit. A high-overhead and a low-overhead practice can collect the same amount and earn very different profits, yet the collections formula assigns them the same value. It can significantly overvalue a low-profit practice and undervalue a highly profitable one.
EBITDA Multiple (DSO And Private-Equity Buyers)
Formula: Practice Value = Normalized EBITDA × Market Multiple
Normalized EBITDA is the practice’s operating profit after adding back discretionary, personal, and non-recurring expenses, and after deducting a market-rate cost to replace the owner’s clinical production. That deduction is the key distinction. A DSO will pay an employed dentist to do the work the owner currently does, so it prices the practice on what it earns after that cost is accounted for.
Common add-backs include the owner’s above-market compensation, personal expenses run through the practice, one-time costs such as a non-recurring legal settlement, and owner benefits. Only add-backs with documentation survive buyer diligence. A one-time expense appearing in three consecutive years will be disallowed.
Published DSO acquisition data places multiples in tiers that climb with practice size. Smaller tuck-in acquisitions tend to price in the lower single digits. Regional add-ons with meaningful EBITDA move into the mid-to-upper single digits. Emerging or platform-scale groups can reach low double digits. Specialty demand, provider count and expandability, revenue durability, and the quality of financial records all move a practice within those ranges. The multiple also reflects the sale process. A single buyer negotiating alone prices differently from several buyers who each know the others exist.
Below roughly $250,000 in adjusted EBITDA, the DSO buyer pool for a dental practice mostly disappears and the practice is often priced on collections or SDE to individual dentists instead. Some DSOs cite a $200,000 EBITDA threshold.
SDE Multiple (The Private-Buyer Middle Method)
Formula: Practice Value = Seller’s Discretionary Earnings × Market Multiple
Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) is the total financial benefit one owner-operator takes from the practice. It includes pre-tax profit plus the owner’s salary, benefits, and any personal or one-time expenses run through the business. SDE measures what one owner-dentist takes home before debt service. It does not deduct a replacement dentist’s cost, because the buying dentist expects to step into the chair.
This structure explains why SDE differs from EBITDA. On the same practice, SDE will be materially higher than adjusted EBITDA because SDE keeps the owner’s full clinical pay in the earnings figure. A 5x SDE offer and a 5x EBITDA offer are not the same price. The SDE-based offer is almost always larger in dollar terms.
Published market data places SDE multiples for practices selling below $2 million at approximately 2.3x to 3.4x, based on IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse Q2 2026 medians. Broader benchmark data places private-buyer dental transactions at roughly 4.0x to 6.5x SDE across the full range. The SDE method is most relevant for practices where an individual dentist buyer is the likely acquirer, typically those collecting under roughly $1.5 million annually. It sits between the collections rule and the EBITDA multiple as a more earnings-sensitive alternative to the collections percentage. Dental practices crossing roughly $750,000 to $1 million in adjusted earnings enter a zone where both private buyers and DSOs compete. In that zone, SDE-based and EBITDA-based valuations can be mismatched if the wrong one is applied.
Why Collections And EBITDA Formulas Diverge
Consider a hypothetical general dental practice with $1.5 million in annual collections and $300,000 in normalized EBITDA. This profile reflects many “middle” owners. The practice is large enough to attract DSO interest, yet still fits a private-buyer path.
Collections-based calculation: At 70% of collections, a commonly cited midpoint for private sales, this practice values at $1,050,000. At 85%, it values at $1,275,000. The range is $225,000 wide before a single profitability figure is considered.
EBITDA-based calculation: A published worked example values a practice with $1.5 million in revenue and $300,000 in EBITDA at an estimated $2 million to a DSO buyer. At a mid-range multiple applied to $300,000 in normalized EBITDA, the DSO path can produce a value meaningfully above what the collections formula generates for the same practice.
The divergence is mechanical rather than arbitrary. The collections formula prices revenue volume, while the EBITDA formula prices profit, specifically the profit that remains after paying someone to replace the owner’s clinical production. A practice with $1.5 million in collections and strong margins produces a very different EBITDA than one with the same collections and high overhead. Yet the collections formula treats them identically.
This difference explains why a side-by-side valuation across both markets matters before an owner chooses a path. The formula that produces the higher number depends on the practice’s specific profitability profile, and that answer changes from practice to practice. For a step-by-step look at how the arithmetic works in a calculator format, see Dental Practice Valuation Calculator: How The Math Works.
What Moves The Number In A Dental Valuation
Two practices with identical collections can be worth very different amounts. Several factors can increase or decrease a dental practice valuation, and understanding their direction and magnitude can be essential before entering any buyer conversation.
- Owner dependence and provider concentration: A practice where the owner produces 90% or more of revenue can see a meaningful valuation reduction because the earnings are difficult to transfer. Associates and hygienists who carry production reduce this risk and support a higher multiple.
- Lease terms and facility: A long, assignable lease protects the location a buyer is paying for. A short lease with no renewal option is priced as a discount. Landlocked suites with limited operatory capacity can also cap the multiple.
- Hygiene and recurring-revenue share: Practices where hygiene production runs above roughly 30% of collections tend to earn a valuation premium. Buyers read hygiene as recurring, transferable revenue that does not walk out the door when the owner leaves.
- Payer mix: Fee-for-service and well-negotiated PPO revenue support the upper end of the range. Medicaid rates land below 50% of what dentists charge across most states, and concentrated low-reimbursement exposure is priced as risk.
- Location and market demand: Growing metropolitan markets can support a premium in DSO transactions. Slower-growth or rural markets may narrow the buyer pool and compress the multiple.
- Equipment and technology: Modern operatories, digital radiography, and current sterilization equipment reduce near-term capital risk for buyers. Aging equipment is discounted because buyers budget to replace what is near end of life.
- Staff stability: Long-tenured staff willing to stay through a transition reduce patient-attrition risk and support value. High turnover or key staff expected to leave with the seller is a negative signal.
- Quality and defensibility of financial records: Add-backs that cannot be documented will be disallowed by buyers. Clean, normalized financials reconciled to bank deposits and tax returns are the foundation of a valuation that holds through diligence.
Which Formula Applies To Your Practice
Practice size and profitability are some of the main inputs to the buyer-path decision, though they do not operate as rigid rules.
Smaller premier practices, commonly in the $1 million to $1.5 million revenue range, most often fit a doctor-to-doctor sale priced on collections or SDE. The private buyer pool is deepest at this size, and the collections or SDE formula reflects what an individual dentist buyer is actually underwriting. The largest practices, those with substantial EBITDA and multiple providers, often point toward the DSO path priced on an EBITDA multiple, where institutional buyers compete for geographic density and scalable cash flow. The available private-buyer pool tends to shrink once a practice reaches roughly $1.5 million in annual revenue, while DSO interest typically requires at least $1 million in revenue and meaningful EBITDA.
Owners in the $1.5 million to $3 million revenue range can genuinely go either way. This group benefits most from a true side-by-side valuation that quantifies the practice’s worth in both markets before a path is chosen.
McLerran & Associates is a suitable advisor for this decision because it runs both paths in roughly equal measure. Every engagement begins with a CPA-led, diligence-grade EBITDA analysis. This analysis unpacks every add-back so the work holds up when buyers scrutinize it and does not get re-traded.

From that foundation, McLerran produces a side-by-side valuation quantifying the practice’s worth in both the private-buyer and DSO markets. It then runs a structured, competitive bid process among a vetted national buyer pool, excluding poorly run buyers, so owners negotiate from strength rather than from a single offer.

When comparing advisors, it helps to know how their models differ. Some generalist appraisal services attached to dental product-and-supply companies operate on a different basis. Those services do not clearly disclose fee structures, which can create pricing-visibility constraints that require contract-level diligence. A potential conflict-of-interest question can arise because the same organization sells equipment and supplies to both practices and DSOs, so sellers should ask in writing who the firm represents in the transaction. McLerran & Associates is sell-side only and never represents the buyer. Its dental-only focus, both-paths structure, CPA-led valuation, vetted national buyer pool, and structured competitive process are documented differentiators, not marketing claims.

Conclusion: Use The Right Formula And Compare Both Paths
A rule-of-thumb percentage functions as a starting point rather than a full valuation. Buyers price on one of three formulas, percentage of collections, SDE multiple, or EBITDA multiple, and the applicable method can depend on the buyer type and the practice’s size and profitability. As noted earlier, McLerran & Associates runs both buyer paths and builds a diligence-grade valuation up front.
The decision framework stays straightforward. Know which formula the buyer will use, understand what moves your number within that formula’s range, and compare both paths before committing to one. The practice that looks average under a collections percentage may look exceptional under a normalized EBITDA analysis, or the reverse. Running both views is the only way to see the full picture.
To explore what your practice may be worth across both markets, you can schedule a free, confidential discovery call with McLerran & Associates. Call (512) 900-7989, email info@dentaltransitions.com, or visit the contact page below.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Much Do Dentists Make When They Sell Their Practice?
The proceeds from a dental practice sale depend on several interacting factors rather than a single figure. The valuation method and buyer type are the starting point. A private doctor-to-doctor sale priced on collections or SDE will typically produce a different headline number than a DSO affiliation priced on EBITDA, even for the same practice.
From there, the actual take-home is shaped by deal structure, meaning how much is paid in cash at closing versus equity rollover or earnout, and by tax treatment. Goodwill is generally taxed at long-term capital gains rates while equipment gains may be taxed as ordinary income through depreciation recapture. Practice size, profitability, payer mix, owner dependence, and the competitiveness of the sale process all influence where within the market range a specific practice lands. Owners who enter a competitive process with a diligence-grade valuation and multiple vetted buyers tend to achieve meaningfully better outcomes than those who negotiate with a single buyer from a back-of-the-napkin number.
What Are The Top 3 Valuation Methods For A Dental Practice?
The three methods buyers and appraisers use most often are the percentage-of-collections method, the SDE multiple, and the EBITDA multiple. The percentage-of-collections method multiplies annual collections by a market percentage and is most common in private doctor-to-doctor sales. It is quick to apply but ignores profitability.
The SDE multiple applies a market multiple to seller’s discretionary earnings, which is profit plus the owner’s full compensation and personal expenses, and is most relevant for owner-operated practices where the buying dentist will work in the chair. The EBITDA multiple applies a market multiple to normalized operating profit after deducting a market-rate cost to replace the owner’s clinical production and is the standard for DSO and private-equity buyers. A defensible valuation reconciles all three rather than relying on one alone.
How Do You Value A Dental Practice For A DSO Sale?
DSO and private-equity buyers price dental practices on normalized EBITDA multiplied by a market multiple. Normalized EBITDA starts with the practice’s operating profit and adds back the owner’s above-market compensation, personal expenses run through the practice, and genuine one-time or non-recurring costs.
It then deducts a market-rate cost to replace the owner’s clinical production, typically calculated as a percentage of the collections the owner personally produces, because the DSO will pay an employed dentist to perform that work after the sale. The resulting figure is smaller than SDE for the same practice, which is why EBITDA multiples appear larger than SDE multiples. The two are not comparable without knowing the earnings base. Every add-back must be documented to survive buyer diligence. Undocumented add-backs are routinely disallowed, which is why a CPA-led normalization done before the deal goes out can be essential to a valuation that holds.
What Factors Increase Or Decrease A Dental Practice Valuation?
Several factors can increase a dental practice’s valuation. Examples include low owner dependence where associates and hygienists carry meaningful production, strong hygiene share and recall rates, a fee-for-service or well-negotiated PPO payer mix, growing collections over the trailing 2 to 3 years, a long and assignable lease with renewal options, modern equipment and technology, long-tenured staff, and clean normalized financials with documented add-backs.
Factors that can decrease valuation include high owner dependence where the owner produces the large majority of revenue, weak hygiene and recall, heavy Medicaid or low-reimbursement plan exposure, declining collections, a short lease with no renewal option, aging or deferred-maintenance equipment, staff instability, and financial records that are difficult to normalize or reconcile. Two practices with identical collections can land at very different valuations based on these factors alone, so the collections rule of thumb functions as a starting point rather than a conclusion.
What Is The Difference Between Goodwill And Asset Value In A Dental Practice Sale?
In a dental practice sale, the purchase price is typically allocated across two broad categories: tangible assets and goodwill. Tangible assets include equipment, technology, furniture, supplies, and leasehold improvements, meaning the physical items that can be inventoried and appraised independently.
Goodwill represents the intangible value of the practice, such as the patient base, staff relationships, systems, reputation, and the practice’s ability to generate revenue under new ownership. In most general dental practices, goodwill accounts for the large majority of the total sale price, with some estimates placing it at 50% to 75% or more of the value.
Goodwill itself is sometimes divided between “personal goodwill,” which is value tied to the selling dentist’s relationships and reputation that may not transfer, and “practice goodwill,” which is value supported by staff continuity, systems, and a planned handoff that is more transferable. Buyers discount personal goodwill heavily because it may leave with the seller. Practice goodwill is what a well-run transition process is designed to protect and transfer. The allocation between asset classes also carries tax consequences for both buyer and seller, since goodwill is generally taxed at long-term capital gains rates while equipment gains may be subject to ordinary income tax through depreciation recapture.
Should I Get A Valuation Before I Decide To Sell?
A valuation before the decision to sell can serve two purposes that a valuation done at listing cannot. First, it sets a defensible anchor, a number built on normalized financials and documented add-backs that reflects what the practice is actually worth rather than what a buyer proposes.
Second, it reveals what to fix. A valuation done 2 to 3 years before a planned sale gives an owner time to grow hygiene share, reduce owner dependence, document add-backs, and let improved earnings show up in the trailing financials buyers actually price. A valuation done the week before listing can only describe the practice as it is. Owners who begin preparing earlier consistently achieve better outcomes than those who decide to sell and list within months.
Why Does A Free Valuation Often Not Hold Up?
A free valuation typically functions as a lead-generation tool rather than a diligence-grade analysis. It is usually built on limited financial data, without the normalization work, such as unpacking every add-back, reconciling collections to bank deposits and tax returns, and deducting a market-rate replacement dentist cost, that a buyer’s quality-of-earnings team will perform.
When a buyer’s advisors scrutinize the numbers and find add-backs that are undocumented, owner compensation that is understated, or overhead that is misclassified, the valuation often gets revised downward. That revision happens after the letter of intent is signed, when the seller has limited leverage to push back. The agreed value gets re-traded, and the owner walks away with less than the headline number suggested. A valuation built to withstand that scrutiny, done before the deal goes out by advisors who understand how buyers underwrite dental practices, is the type that tends to hold.